➽ The Myth of Nations Download ➺ Author Patrick J. Geary – Turboville.co.uk


The Myth of Nations The Myth of Nations is the third book in my trilogy of Late Antique histories, the first two being Frontiers of the Roman Empire and Barbarian Tides Unlike these titles, the current book is not an academic work Instead, Geary s audience is the general reader with an interest in history p 185 Beyond that, he wants to argue that modern national identities are the products of 18th and 19th century European state building In reality, identity whether constitutional or organic is a con The Myth of Nations is the third book in my trilogy of Late Antique histories, the first two being Frontiers of the Roman Empire and Barbarian Tides Unlike these titles, the current book is not an academic work Instead, Geary s audience is the general reader with an interest in history p 185 Beyond that, he wants to argue that modern national identities are the products of 18th and 19th century European state building In reality, identity whether constitutional or organic is a concept always in flux, and, in Late Antiquity say, AD 400 800 , things were exceptionally fluid.I don t have too much to say about the book Geary s main po Ve ina re enica iz slede eg teksta je prepisana iz knjige Ja sam ih samo malo sredio kako bih dobio kompaktan tekst.Nacionalizam je tvorevina romantizma 19 veka u kombinaciji sa nau nom istorijom i indoevropskom filologijom Nema tu ni eg drevnog Pogleda na pro lost je zamagljen istorijskim istra ivanjima u poslednja dva veka Nacionalisti ke istorije se pre temelje na politi kim i kulturnim shvatanjima autora koji ih pi u nego na stvarnim injenicama.Nacionalisti ke metode obuhvataju najpr Ve ina re enica iz slede eg teksta je prepisana iz knjige Ja sam ih samo malo sredio kako bih dobio kompaktan tekst.Nacionalizam je tvorevina romantizma 19 veka u kombinaciji sa nau nom istorijom i indoevropskom filologijom Nema tu ni eg dre Patrick Geary s Myth of Nations endeavors to prove that the national definitions of European nations are inaccurate due to the fluid nature of early European people groups Further he hopes to establish these definitions as political and racial in origin while shining a light on the role of historians in crafting this inaccurate narrative from the past This misinterpretation of the past, Geary postulates, has been co opted by nationalistic movements, which have summoned millions of people int Patrick Geary s Myth of Nations endeavors to prove that the national definitions of European nations are inaccurate due to the fluid nat Wonderful incisive look at the changing ideas of nationhood which disputes any idea of fixed national identities stemming from some distant past When contemporary nationalists appeal to history, their notion of history is static they look to the moment of primary acquisition, when their people, first arriving in the ruins of the Roman Empire, established their sacred territory and their national identity This is the very antithesis of history The history of European peoples in Late Antiqu Wonderful incisive look at the changing ideas of nationhood which disputes any idea of fixed national identities stemming from some distant past When contemporary nationalists appeal to history, their notion of history is static they look to the moment of primary acquisition, when their people, first arriving in the ruins of the Roman Empire, established their sacred territory and their national identity This is the very antithesis of history The history of European peoples in Late Antiquit It s an obligatory classic for anyone taking a real interest in history I haven t read it in my undergrad years, as the Polish historiography has its own excellent classic title covering the same subject area see wit narod w europejskich Now, it pleases me to see that the English speaking world has also pro I definitely liked it, and it pretty much shook my entire perception of peoplehood reading the brief section on the Bulgars and how they had split from the Avars is totally and utterly unlike anything I was taught in school in terms of the origins of the Bulgars Being Bulgarian, this really caused me to reconsider everything I was taught about our historical continuity as a people a concept which really is quite ridiculous Geary does a great job in describing the fluidity of identity and h I definitely liked it, and it pretty much shook my entire perception of peoplehood reading the brief section on the Bulgars and how they had split from the Avars is totally and utterly unlike anything I was taught in school in terms of the origins of the Bulgars Being Bulgarian, this really caused me to reconsider everything I was taught about our historical continuity as a people a concept which really is quite ridiculous Geary does a great job in describing the fluidity of identity and how ethnicity or peoplehood is a construct, that peoples are heterogenous units, constantly evolving and amalg Modern Day Europeans By The Millions Proudly Trace Back Their National Identities To The Celts, Franks, Gauls, Goths, Huns, Or Serbs Or Some Combination Of The Various Peoples Who Inhabited, Traversed, Or Pillaged Their Continent Than A Thousand Years Ago According To Patrick Geary, This Is Historical Nonsense The Idea That National Character Is Fixed For All Time In A Simpler, Distant Past Is Groundless, He Argues In This Unflinching Reconsideration Of European Nationhood Few Of The Peoples That Many Europeans Honor As Sharing Their Sense Of Nation Had Comparably Homogeneous Identities Even The Huns, He Points Out, Were Firmly United Only Under Attila S Ten Year Reign.Geary Dismantles The Nationalist Myths About How The Nations Of Europe Were Born Through Rigorous Analysis Set In Lucid Prose, He Contrasts The Myths With The Actual History Of Europe S Transformation Between The Fourth And Ninth Centuries The Period Of Grand Migrations That Nationalists Hold Dear The Nationalist Sentiments Today Increasingly Taken For Granted In Europe Emerged, He Argues, Only In The Nineteenth Century Ironically, This Phenomenon Was Kept Alive Not Just By Responsive Populations But By Complicit Scholars.Ultimately, Geary Concludes, The Actual Formation Of European Peoples Must Be Seen As An Extended Process That Began In Antiquity And Continues In The Present The Resulting Image Is A Challenge To Those Who Anchor Contemporary Antagonisms In Ancient Myths To Those Who Claim That Immigration And Tolerance Toward Minorities Despoil Nationhood As Geary Shows, Such Ideologues Whether Le Pens Who Champion The French People Born With The Baptism Of Clovis In 496 Or Milosevics Who Cite Early Serbian History To Claim Rebellious Regions Know Their Myths But Not Their History The Myth Of Nations Will Be Intensely Debated By All Who Understood That A History That Does Not Change, That Reduces The Complexities Of Many Centuries To A Single, Eternal Moment, Isn T History At All. Very good book on the strange modern idea of nationalism.What is a nation It is an idea, mostly a lie that philologists made up, and then political states took to legitimize their power and justify reclaiming land that rightfully belongs to them.This is why I like Thucydides so much This book was a great source of thoughts And a liberating read. An interesting take, especially in light of books I ve read since such as Leithart s Defending Constantine.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About the Author: Patrick J. Geary

Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the The Myth of Nations book, this is one of the most wanted Patrick J. Geary author readers around the world.